Employer Deducted TDS but Did Not Deposit It – Can the Employee Be Asked to Pay Again?
Orissa High Court Gives Relief to Salaried Taxpayers
In Nirupama Nanda v. State of Odisha & Ors., W.P.(C) No. 12607 of 2026, 2026 LLBiz HC (ODI) 27, decided on 12 October 2026, the Orissa High Court held that an employee cannot be made to pay income tax again to the extent tax has already been deducted from salary, merely because the employer failed to deposit the TDS or report it correctly, resulting in a mismatch in Form 26AS.
Background
The petitioner, a former college lecturer, had tax deducted from her salary for Assessment Years 2010-11 to 2013-14. However, the Principal of the college did not correctly report these deductions in the TDS returns. For AY 2013-14 alone, ₹3,92,913 was deducted from her salary but not reflected properly. As a result, the credit was missing or incorrectly shown in her Form 26AS, and the Department raised outstanding demands.
She applied to the Income Tax Officer in 2016 for rectification, submitting salary certificates and TDS details, but her requests were not addressed. The Department maintained that TDS credit can be given only when the amount is deposited with the Government and appears in Form 26AS.
High Court’s Ruling
A Division Bench of Justice Sanjeeb K. Panigrahi and Justice Murahari Sri Raman held that the employee should not suffer for the employer’s default. Under Section 205, recovery of tax cannot be made from the deductee to the extent tax has already been deducted from his or her income. The duty to deposit the deducted tax lies on the deductor, who can be treated as an assessee in default under Section 201.
The Court relied on earlier decisions including Kartik Vijaysinh Sonavane v. CIT, Chintan Bindra v. CIT and Malay Kar v. Union of India, and observed that the taxpayer cannot be put to double jeopardy where deducted tax is not reflected correctly.
The petitioner was directed to file supporting documents within 15 days. The Assessing Officer must verify the deductions – calling for confirmation from the employers or summoning records if needed – and rectify the outstanding demands within three months if the claim is established.
Significance of the Decision
Form 26AS mismatches are one of the most common reasons for demands raised on salaried individuals. This judgment confirms that once tax is deducted from salary, the employee has discharged the liability to that extent, and the Department must recover any shortfall from the employer, not from the employee.
Key Takeaways
- Section 205 bars recovery from the employee to the extent tax has been deducted from salary.
- Non-deposit or incorrect reporting by the employer does not shift the burden to the employee.
- The Department’s remedy lies against the deductor under Section 201.
- Employees should preserve Form 16, salary slips and salary certificates as proof of TDS deducted.
Conclusion
The Orissa High Court’s ruling protects salaried taxpayers from paying the same tax twice. It reinforces that an employee cannot be penalised for the employer’s failure to deposit or report TDS.
Penalty Cannot Be Imposed While the Appeal Is Pending Before ITAT
Delhi High Court Quashes Section 270A Penalty Order
In BT Global Communications India Pvt. Ltd. v. Assessment Unit, NFAC & Anr., W.P.(C) 4767/2023, 2026 LLBiz HC (DEL) 1127, the Delhi High Court held that a penalty order under Section 270A passed while the assessee’s appeal is pending before the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal is invalid, as Section 275(1)(a) requires penalty proceedings to be kept in abeyance during such appeal.
Background
For Assessment Year 2018-19, the assessment order was passed on 28 July 2022, and penalty proceedings under Section 270A were initiated on the same day. The assessee replied to the penalty notice on 17 August 2022 and filed an appeal before the ITAT on 29 August 2022, informing the Assessing Officer about it.
Despite the pending appeal, the Assessing Officer passed the penalty order on 24 March 2023. The Revenue argued that the assessment order itself recorded that the assessee was only in the process of filing an appeal.
High Court’s Ruling
A Division Bench of Justice Dinesh Mehta and Justice Aditi Choudhary noted that the penalty order’s reference to the appeal appeared to be copied from the assessee’s earlier reply. It was undisputed that the appeal had in fact been filed before the ITAT and that the Assessing Officer had been informed.
The Court held that whether or not intimation of the appeal was given is immaterial. Once an appeal under Section 253 is pending before the Tribunal, Section 275(1)(a) mandates that penalty proceedings remain in abeyance. The penalty order was quashed, with liberty to the Assessing Officer to start penalty proceedings afresh only if the Tribunal decides the appeal against the assessee.
Significance of the Decision
In faceless proceedings, penalty orders are often passed mechanically without checking the status of appeals. This judgment confirms that the statutory protection under Section 275(1)(a) is mandatory and penalty orders passed in breach of it are liable to be set aside.
Key Takeaways
- Penalty proceedings must be kept in abeyance while the quantum appeal is pending before the ITAT.
- A penalty order passed during pendency of the appeal is invalid, even if the AO claims lack of intimation.
- The AO may restart penalty proceedings only after the Tribunal decides against the assessee.
- Assessees should promptly inform the AO of the appeal filed and keep proof of filing on record.
Conclusion
The Delhi High Court has reaffirmed that penalty follows the fate of the quantum appeal. Until the Tribunal decides the appeal, the Assessing Officer cannot impose a penalty on the disputed addition.

Non-Compete Fee Paid to Former MD Is Revenue Expenditure – Even If Paid in Instalments
Bombay High Court Rules in Favour of Tata Chemicals
In PCIT-2 v. Tata Chemicals Ltd., Income Tax Appeal No. 2390 of 2018, 2026 LLBiz HC (BOM) 570, decided on 8 October 2026, the Bombay High Court held that payments made to a former employee under a non-compete agreement are allowable as revenue expenditure under Section 37(1), even when the amount is paid in instalments over several financial years.
Background
Under a settlement agreement, Tata Chemicals paid ₹40 lakh to its former Managing Director, who agreed not to compete with the company and not to disclose confidential information obtained during his employment. The payment was made over three financial years and claimed as business expenditure.
The Assessing Officer disallowed the claim, treating the payment as capital expenditure. The Revenue argued that the Supreme Court’s earlier ruling on non-compete payments did not apply because the amount was paid in instalments. The Income Tax Appellate Tribunal allowed the deduction, holding that the payment only protected the existing business and did not create any new asset.
High Court’s Ruling
A Division Bench of Justice Suman Shyam and Justice Gautam A. Ankhad dismissed the Revenue’s appeal. Following the Supreme Court’s decision in Sharp Business System v. CIT, the Court held that a payment made to prevent competition protects the business and its profitability but does not create a new asset or an enduring advantage of a capital nature.
The Court further held that once the payment is revenue in nature, it makes no difference whether it is paid in a lump sum or in instalments over different years.
The Court also upheld the deduction for expenditure on projects that were later written off, as the expenditure related to improvements of existing plants and did not result in any new asset.
Significance of the Decision
Settlements with exiting senior management commonly include non-compete and confidentiality obligations, with payments often spread over time. This judgment confirms that the tax character of such payments depends on their purpose, not on the payment schedule, giving companies certainty while structuring such arrangements.
Key Takeaways
- Non-compete fees that protect an existing business are deductible under Section 37(1).
- Payment in instalments does not convert a revenue expense into a capital expense.
- Expenditure on written-off projects relating to existing plants is allowable where no new asset is created.
- Agreements and board approvals should clearly record the business purpose of such payments.
Conclusion
The Bombay High Court’s decision brings welcome clarity on the treatment of non-compete payments. It reaffirms that an expense is judged by what it achieves for the business, not by how or when it is paid.